News An Introduction to Whiplash

An Introduction to Whiplash


Whiplash is one of the most controversial conditions in the health care field and has major implications in the legal and insurance industries as well.

In 1989, the agency which heads up the insurance business in the Canadian province of Quebec sponsored the largest in-depth look into the phenomenon of whiplash and whiplash-related disorders ever undertaken. The Quebec Task Force, as it was called, brought out its report in 1995 and stated that ‘Whiplash is to the automobile, what low back pain is to the workplace.’

The only definitive fact that can be said about whiplash is that it occurs in motor vehicle accidents. All other aspects of the whiplash phenomenon are subject to a degree of debate and controversy. The types of injuries sustained, the mechanics and degrees of these injuries, the validity and legitimacy of the injuries, the best treatments, the effect of litigation on the clinical outcome, the psychological factors, and the concept of secondary gain, are all issues open to debate in the discussion of whiplash. Not even insurance statistics concerning the incidence of whiplash can find consensus. Statistics range from 3.8 to 14.5 per thousand traffic accidents in the U.S. to 20% of all motor vehicle accidents in Quebec to 68% of all claims in Saskatchewan.

Even scientific literature on the subject is full of controversy. The Quebec Task Force reviewed over 10,000 articles on the subject and subsequently rejected most due to irrelevancy or on the grounds of poor scientific merit. Only 62 of 10,000 scientific articles were considered worthy of study by the Task Force.

The Quebec Task Force, made up of a cross-section of health care clinicians and researchers, was itself widely praised and just as widely criticized. This was to be expected in view of the great variety of opinions on the subject as well as the fact that the study was sponsored by the auto insurance industry. However, one or two studies, no matter how meritorious cannot be expected to provide all the answers nor address all the ongoing health and legal issues to everyone’s satisfaction. The fact that many of the Task Force’s recommendations have whole-heartedly been adopted by many premium and cheap auto insurance companies itself raises suspicions that the report may have been somewhat self-serving.

One of the most controversial aspects of the report was that it stated that after one year post-accident only 1.8% of whiplash victims still suffered from chronic neck and head pain. Obviously, this was music to the ears of insurance adjusters and gave ample grounds to terminate benefits aggressively. The fact that several other researchers have since placed the figure at closer to 12% has barely fazed insurance officials in their quest for profits.

An Introduction to Whiplash
General Contributor
Janice is a writer from Chicago, IL. She created the "simple living as told by me" newsletter with more than 12,000 subscribers about Living Better and is a founder of Seekyt.

Latest news

Japanese Owl Meaning and Symbolism

If you're wondering about the Japanese owl meaning and symbolism in Asian cultures, the Owl, along with Maneki Neko...

What Are the Signs of Depression in Women

Gender and depression have long been the scope of research in the field of emotional disorders; most authors believe...

Top 7 Superfoods for Men to Stay Young

Superfoods are generally regarded as targeted foods that provide the maximum nutritional benefit - thus these foods are nutritionally-dense...

Best Brain foods for Kids – Boost Brain Power and Keep Sharp

A child's brain is developing rapidly and if you want them to improve their performance in school and their...

7 of the Best Brain Foods for Studying

The foods that you eat can improve the functioning of your brain. Just like drugs, foods have amino acids,...

B12 Shots for Dogs – 10 Key Benefits

The end of 2010, my little dog -- a 7-pound Papillon -- became very stressed after a flood in...

Must read

Short Green Cocktail Dresses

If you are looking for a great look for...

How to get rid of termites

Get rid of termites Termites are harmful...
- Advertisement -

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you